Exploring healthcare barriers and content of short-term psychodynamic therapies engaging with adult transdiagnostic persistent physical symptoms (PPS): what can be learnt to enhance physical and psychological healthcare interventions for PPS? a systematic scoping review (1999–2024): What Can Be Learnt to Enhance Physical and Psychological Healthcare Interventions for PPS? A Systematic Scoping Review (1999–2024)
- Jean Penman(corresponding author),
- Jane Williams,
- Martin Gryszkiewicz-MacKenzie,
- British Association for Counselling & Psychotherapy,
- British Association forBehavioural and Cognitive Therapies (BABCP),
- ,
Research Output:
Contribution to journal
Review article
Research
Peer-reviewOpen access
Sustainable Development Goals
- SDG 3 Good Health and Well
Abstract
ABSTRACT
Persistent physical symptoms (PPS) lasting more than 6 months represent a significant healthcare burden in the United Kingdom. PPS may not be disabling in terms of daily living but can deeply affect the wellbeing of an individual subject to ineffective healthcare provision. The barriers to implementing therapeutic interventions in healthcare require further enquiry. This paper supports the scope of what works to broaden beyond cognitive behavioural therapies (CBT) to discover a wider range of therapeutic interventions. Less well-understood brief psychodynamic therapies (BPTs) require further exploration of their content, specifically for PPS conditions.
Objectives
This scoping review aims to clarify the current definition and barriers to the delivery of effective PPS care, and to map common themes of PPS-effective BPTs for future research and practice.
Method
A preliminary scoping (1999–2024) is undertaken to identify barriers to care inclusive of PPS definitions and the content of UK Professional guidelines. Next, quality-checked mixed-method studies of adult BPT interventions for PPS undergo pre-designed data charting (2001–2024). The BPT augmentations are mapped and thematically collated.
Results
Barriers include an inconsistent definition of transdiagnostic PPS, the lack of effective care pathways and inadequate UK professional, CPD and clinical guidelines. BPTs with clinically relevant PPS reductions revealed strong and moderate quality evidence of longer term outcomes. A thematic analysis of the PPS-focused BPT content was achieved.
Conclusions
Several opportunities to reduce barriers to effective PPS care are readily identified. The indicative observations of effective outcomes and thematic mapping of the content of BPT indicate promise for enhancing PPS intervention development across disciplines. Further research into practice is required.
Persistent physical symptoms (PPS) lasting more than 6 months represent a significant healthcare burden in the United Kingdom. PPS may not be disabling in terms of daily living but can deeply affect the wellbeing of an individual subject to ineffective healthcare provision. The barriers to implementing therapeutic interventions in healthcare require further enquiry. This paper supports the scope of what works to broaden beyond cognitive behavioural therapies (CBT) to discover a wider range of therapeutic interventions. Less well-understood brief psychodynamic therapies (BPTs) require further exploration of their content, specifically for PPS conditions.
Objectives
This scoping review aims to clarify the current definition and barriers to the delivery of effective PPS care, and to map common themes of PPS-effective BPTs for future research and practice.
Method
A preliminary scoping (1999–2024) is undertaken to identify barriers to care inclusive of PPS definitions and the content of UK Professional guidelines. Next, quality-checked mixed-method studies of adult BPT interventions for PPS undergo pre-designed data charting (2001–2024). The BPT augmentations are mapped and thematically collated.
Results
Barriers include an inconsistent definition of transdiagnostic PPS, the lack of effective care pathways and inadequate UK professional, CPD and clinical guidelines. BPTs with clinically relevant PPS reductions revealed strong and moderate quality evidence of longer term outcomes. A thematic analysis of the PPS-focused BPT content was achieved.
Conclusions
Several opportunities to reduce barriers to effective PPS care are readily identified. The indicative observations of effective outcomes and thematic mapping of the content of BPT indicate promise for enhancing PPS intervention development across disciplines. Further research into practice is required.
Publication Information
Output type
Research Output:
Contribution to journal
Review article
Research
Peer-reviewOriginal language
EnglishArticle number
e70205Pages from-to (Number of pages)
Pages 1-17 (17 pages)Journal (Volume, Issue Number)
Counselling and Psychotherapy Research (Volume 26, Issue 4)Publication milestones
- Accepted/In press - 21/07/2026
- E-pub ahead of print - 06/10/2026
- Published - 06/10/2026
Publication status
Published - 06/10/2026
ISSN
1473-3145Publication IDs
- Scopus: 105052753673
Access to documents
Accepted author manuscript, 538.81 KB
License:CC BY-NC-ND, opens in new tab
Final published version
Handle.net
Publication metrics
Metrics
Download statistics
Download count
7
